There may come a point when you decide it's time to update your home's front door. Or maybe you're in the process of flipping a house and that property needs a new front door before being put on the market. You have a few choices to consider, and you may be wondering whether fiberglass is the best option for your front door or if it pays to go with steel instead. Here, we'll review both to help you decide.
Fiberglass front doors are very attractive and add to curb appeal, which tends to be a big draw for homeowners and buyers. Fiberglass can be made to look like wood, which is something many people seek.
Here are some additional benefits of fiberglass doors:
- They're durable.
- They can be painted any color you want to match your exterior and taste.
- They're energy-efficient, blocking cold air during winter and helping retain cool air indoors during summer.
- They're easy to clean and maintain.
- They're resistant to extreme temperatures.
However, there's one major downside to fiberglass: It's less secure than steel for your front door. If safety is a concern, steel may be a better choice.
Steel front doors provide more protection than fiberglass because they're thicker and harder to break into. As such, they make a better security door.
Here are some additional benefits of steel doors:
- They're less expensive than fiberglass.
- They're easy to maintain.
But steel doors have their drawbacks, too:
- They come in limited colors and can't be painted.
- They may rust over time.
- They're not as energy-efficient as fiberglass, so if you live someplace with extreme temperatures, they may not be the most comfortable choice.
What do fiberglass and steel doors cost?
Steel doors cost an average of $2,000, according to the National Association of Realtors (NAR). By contrast, fiberglass doors cost an average of $2,700.
Fiberglass vs. steel: Which is the better investment?
When it comes to return on investment (ROI), you'll have comparable results with both fiberglass and steel. NAR data reveals the average cost recovery percentage for fiberglass doors is 74%. For steel doors, it's 75%.
As such, you may need to ask yourself:
- What's my budget for a new front door? Steel is apt to cost less.
- What's more important -- aesthetics or security? Steel offers better protection but may not look quite as nice (though some steel doors are perfectly nice-looking in their own right).
- How important is energy efficiency? Fiberglass may be a better option if you live someplace where winters are freezing and summers are sweltering.
The bottom line
Ultimately, a new front door is a good investment in a home you're planning to live in or sell, so weigh these factors when making your decision. You may also want to roam your immediate neighborhood and see what your neighbors' front doors are made of. That could give you an idea as to the most ideal choice for your property.