Group-focused hotels have been hit really hard
I'd actually call Ryman's assets and long-term growth potential the best of the three companies here, and its balance sheet is perhaps the most solid. So why is it the worst-performing REIT in this discussion?
The short answer is that Ryman's business has been hit by the pandemic far worse than most hotel REITs. The company owns five large-scale luxury hotels that operate under the Gaylord brand name, as well as a portfolio of entertainment assets such as the Grand Ole Opry and Ryman Auditorium venues and the up-and-coming Ole Red restaurant chain. Ryman's hotels are among the largest group-focused hotel properties outside of the gaming industry, and conferences and conventions are simply not happening right now. And it's a bad time to be the owner of concert venues when large gatherings are largely being postponed until at least 2021.
That said, I'm a major believer in Ryman's business from a long-term perspective. To illustrate just how much demand there is for group events, Ryman has successfully rebooked 457,000 cancelled room nights and actually has more net room nights on its books for 2021 and 2022 than it did at this point last year.
Ryman has a portfolio of unique and extremely valuable hotel and entertainment assets that should thrive in the post-pandemic world. With plenty of liquidity to get through the tough times, now could be a great time to add Ryman to your portfolio at a huge discount.
When business travel rebounds, so will this REIT
Apple Hospitality Properties invests in mid-range hotel properties, a category referred to as "select-service" hotels. The company currently owns 233 hotel properties, averaging about 125 rooms each. The idea is that these are smaller and require less ongoing capital expenditure than luxury properties but offer a higher level of amenities than discount motel chains.
Just to give you an idea of what we're talking about, Hilton Garden Inn, Hampton, Residence Inn, and Homewood Suites are some of the major brands in the company's hotel portfolio. These types of hotel require relatively little staffing and maintenance and operate at higher margins than higher-end properties.
One key point to know is that these hotels cater to business travelers, an area of the travel industry that tends to hold up better than leisure travel during recessions. Obviously, business travel ground to a halt this year, but as things start to normalize, Apple Hospitality Properties should be in a good position to rebound.
Because people want to get out
Xenia Hotels & Resorts focuses on the higher end of the hotel industry, with 39 luxury resorts in some of the top leisure and lodging markets in the United States. Just to name a few, Westin, Ritz-Carlton, Hyatt Regency, and Kimpton are some of Xenia's hotel brands.
In a nutshell, Xenia benefits when people are willing and able to travel to their favorite destinations. Two-thirds of the properties in the company's portfolio remained closed at the end of May, which is certainly understandable as no non-essential travel was happening in the spring, and when people travel for essential purposes, large-scale destination resorts are typically not the top choice, especially when amenities like bars, restaurants, and pools cannot be used.
Most of Xenia's properties are expected to reopen by the end of July and all are expected to be operational by October. Xenia has taken steps to ensure ample liquidity and is even taking advantage of the temporary shutdowns to accelerate some of its planned renovations.
Xenia has a highly experienced management team that has a great track record of value creation. Its hotels are in very desirable locations and are operated under some of the most well-known luxury brand names in the industry. The next year or so could be quite a roller coaster ride, but this is a business that should do quite well once all the pent-up demand is unleashed on the leisure travel market.
Invest with the long term in mind
Hotel REITs are a relatively volatile type of real estate stock even in strong economic times, so that's likely to be the case even more during times of uncertainty. I'd expect quite a roller coaster ride in these hotel REITs as the pandemic continues, and if things get worse before they get better, we could see these stocks come under pressure.
The bottom line is that these hotel REITs should reward investors who have the patience and risk tolerance to hang on through the tough times, but there's no telling where they'll go in the near term. Invest accordingly.