Though COVID-19 didn't originate in Italy, it's now considered the epicenter of the outbreak. Not only have Italians been on lockdown for weeks, but the country's healthcare system is already overtaxed and overwhelmed.
Italian citizens are overwhelmed, too, and many of those who aren't grappling with health concerns are dealing with financial worries. As such, Italy has suspended all mortgage payments for homeowners as it grapples with the crisis that's shaken it to its core.
Of course, the U.S. is far from immune to COVID-19's wrath. With cases popping up by the thousands daily as testing ramps up, millions of Americans risk not only health issues but financial problems as well as they're increasingly forced out of work in an effort to maintain social distancing -- the one tactic that's presumed useful at this point in limiting COVID-19's spread. In fact, a large number of homeowners may already be facing a gap in income and the possibility of not being able to make their next mortgage payment.
The question is, will the U.S. follow in Italy's footsteps by suspending mortgages temporarily, or will homeowners be left to fend for themselves?
A similar approach is unlikely
It stands to reason that if people are being told not to go to work, their ability to earn money will go away if their job can't be done remotely. Once that happens, paying a mortgage becomes impossible for those without hefty savings in the bank.
But is the U.S. likely to suspend mortgages across the board on a temporary basis? Probably not.
For one thing, based on how mortgages are drafted, it would be extremely difficult to enforce a universal suspension at the federal level. Furthermore, halting mortgage payments may address a short-term need but leave a lasting problem in its wake. If payments are suspended but interest continues to accrue during that time, and then gets added back onto those payments once the suspension period ends, homeowners could face higher monthly payments just as things start to get back to normal, leaving them in a tight spot financially once their income picks back up. Also, the U.S. has a lot more cumulative mortgage debt than Italy, and so suspending mortgages across the board would have greater economic implications.